Monday, December 18, 2006

More RSS

For step 9 in the 23 Things, we are to review four RSS search tool websites. For testing the searches, I will use my favorite search phrase "Italian Greyhound".

Technorati This is a nice site with Popular, Top Searches, and Top Tags visible on the homepage. There is a simple search and an advanced search. Interestingly, I got no results when I search Italian Greyhound as a phrase, but I still found plenty of IG information if I used the all words option.

On the results page, I really like the "In [24 hours; 2 days, 3 days, etc.]" along the left side. There is a graph showing Mentions by Day which is pretty neat. Furthermore, there are a number of options where you can limit your search. Too bad I found the site buggy; I got an error message every third search.

The one thing I did not like is the Featured Bloggers. All you have are thumbnail images and you have to either roll the mouse over each image to get a name or click on it to get more information. I think they need to rethink this one.


Feedster Not as colorful as Technorati and the search options are limited, but at least I would remember the name better than Technorati.

Feedster offers Content Channels, Popular Searches, Business Solutions, Feed of the Day (with a thumbnail screenshot), and Feedster in the News.

The worst thing is the search options or lack thereof. Plus, Feedster does not show the link for each feed. I like to know where I am getting my information. Of course, neither did Technorati, so maybe that just isn't part of RSS feed searches.


Topix
appears like an online newspaper with Top Story, Latest News, and Local News. I especially like the Recent Comments where you can find some interesting stuff.

The Advance Search doesn't offer as many options as Technorati, but it is designed more for searching news that subjects.

At the bottom of the homepage are additional news separated by topic like sections in a print newspaper. Overall, a nice site for news and comments.


Syndic8 I left this one for last. What a mess. This site is designed as a "community-driven effort" (think Wikipedia).

There's a lot going on on this page, but a lot of garbage too. Why should I care about random sites and random headlines? Moreover, why should I care about the 10 Newest Users? Am I supposed to know these people?

The only redeeming quality of this site is the search results, but not the search itself (I'll get to that). I like that I can see the site names, when it was created, "feed changed" (I'm assuming that means last updated), and language. Plus, I can sort by each of these columns.

There is a Recent Search list, but it seems to have recent searches for everyone since it shows searches like Car Insurance. I didn't search for any car insurance. Does this mean I can get a discount on my car insurance if I have an Italian Greyhound?

Although there are a number of options for various sources (listed along the top of the page in no particular order), Syndic8 offers no advanced search and using quotations for a phrase search resulted in no hits.

In conclusion, I would stay away from this site.

No comments: